Sarah Edwards | October 21, 2022
Summary: An affirmative defense is a legal defense that a defendant uses to prove they are not liable. In a debt collection lawsuit, an affirmative defense is any legal reason that the defendant should not be held responsible for the debt. You must list your affirmative defenses when you respond to a debt lawsuit. SoloSuit can help you use the right defense the right way.
You're likely wondering what to do if you receive notice of a lawsuit for an old debt. Receiving a warning of a pending case against you is scary. After all, no one wants to be on the wrong side of the law.
Once you’ve had time to read through the details of the lawsuit and identify who the plaintiff (the person or company suing you) is, it’s time to figure out how to defend yourself. You can pay off or negotiate the debt before the court date, allow the lawsuit to proceed with no comment, or defend yourself.
Deciding to pay off or negotiate your debt before the court date has advantages. You’ll be able to rid yourself of the liability and move on with your life, free of any potential judgment.
If you decide to let the plaintiff bring their claims to court, you’ll likely receive a default judgment. The judgment will force you to pay the debt, and the plaintiff can take legal action to collect the money from you via your paycheck or bank account.
Defending yourself is another option. However, few people know how to protect themselves in a debt collection lawsuit. Most individuals assume they have no defense since they technically owe the money.
However, this isn’t true. You likely have several defenses you can use in court, known as affirmative defenses. In this article, we’ll discuss what affirmative sefense is and which ones may apply to a debt collection lawsuit.
An affirmative defense is an argument where the defendant (the person or company being sued) provides evidence that negates their culpability in a civil liability case. In other words, an affirmative defense is any legal reason that you shouldn’t lose the case. Affirmative defenses are helpful even when the defendant is technically guilty. If the defendant can prove an affirmative defense, the judge will dismiss the lawsuit against them.
Deciding to use an affirmative defense is a bit risky in some cases. Remember that the plaintiff has the burden of proving the validity of their lawsuit against you. If you decide to use an affirmative defense in your case, the burden of proof shifts to you.
You must fully demonstrate how the affirmative defense applies and answer questions from the plaintiff, judge, or others to substantiate your claim.
Affirmative defenses can be helpful if you know what they are and how to use them. Most creditors and debt collectors file lawsuits to collect old debts because they assume the debtor will either pay off the claim or let the judgment to proceed. They don’t anticipate that the borrower will stand up for themselves in court.
If you effectively use an affirmative defense in a debt lawsuit against you, you may achieve one of the best outcomes: a complete dismissal of your case.Read on to learn more about affirmative defenses that can help you win your debt collection case.
Attorneys commonly use more than 200 affirmative defenses in civil and criminal cases. However, not all of these defenses will apply to a debt collection case. (Note: all debt collection cases are considered civil cases). We’ve identified 8 of the most common affirmative defenses that may apply when you get sued for debt:
Now, let’s break down each of these affirmative defenses in detail. You can also watch this video to learn more about how to use affirmative defenses to win your lawsuit:
One of the first defenses you should consider is the statute of limitations. Each state has a statute of limitations outlining how long a creditor or collector can pursue legal action on an old debt. In other words, the statute of limitations set a deadline for someone to be able to sue you for a debt you owe.
Frequently, the statute of limitations varies depending on the debt owed. For instance, the times creditors have to collect on debts involving promissory notes (such as automobile loans) and revolving accounts (such as credit cards) may differ.
Most statutes of limitations on debt vary from three to ten years. Kentucky has one of the longest limitations on debt—creditors can file a lawsuit up to fifteen years from the date of a promissory note involving a student loan, automobile, or real estate purchase.
Individuals facing debt collection deal with creditors and debt collectors. Debt collectors work for companies that purchase old debts at a bargain price and attempt to collect them from the original borrowers. Several years may have come and gone by the time a debt collector purchases your debt. In some cases, the statute of limitations may expire.
While the statute of limitations can’t stop debt collectors from sending letters or calling you in pursuit of debt, it can prevent them from winning a lawsuit against you.
Let’s take a look at an example.
Example: Franklin is being sued by a debt collector in California for an old credit card debt of $800. When Franklin hears about the case, he doesn’t even remember the debt. After some investigating, he finds out that the debt account has been inactive for more than six years. Since the statute of limitations on credit card debt is four years in California, the debt collector does not have the legal right to sue for it. Franklin uses SoloSuit to draft and file his Answer to the lawsuit, where he uses the expired statute of limitations as one of his affirmative defenses. The case gets dismissed.
If you receive notice of an intent to sue for a debt you know nothing about, you may be the victim of identity theft.
Identity theft is, sadly, widespread. Criminals can find your personal details, like your Social Security number, name, and address, and use the information to obtain money from a lending institution.
Consumers are well-advised to keep a close eye on their credit reports and notify creditors if a new balance appears that isn’t theirs. However, not all consumers regularly check their reports, and sometimes the first time they notice something is amiss is when a debt collector attempts to sue them for the stolen money.
Individuals sued for a debt that isn’t theirs must follow the appropriate steps to report the theft and notify the debt collector. The debt collector cannot act against the individual unless the authorities find that identity theft did not occur.
It’s rare for a debt collector to sue for a paid debt, but it does happen. Occasionally lines get crossed, and the creditor doesn’t update their files appropriately, resulting in a lawsuit for a debt you no longer owe.
In other cases, debtors pay off their liability before the court case date. If a collector receives full payment before the court date, they will need to dismiss their claims.
Sometimes, individuals may negotiate a payment plan or a reduced payoff before the court date. If your creditor agrees to a payment plan or settlement, make sure to obtain the arrangement in writing. You can use a copy of the agreement to have your case dismissed.
One intriguing affirmative defense is no business relationship between the debt collector and the consumer. This defense may work if the party suing you for a debt is not the original creditor.
To prove that no business relationship exists between you and the creditor, you must show that the original debt was with another lender, like a financial institution or bank. The defense strengthens if you show that the debt collector increased the original owed balance when they purchased the old debt.
Sometimes, people become so overwhelmed by debt they simply can’t foresee a way out. In such cases, they may file for bankruptcy to obtain a fresh start.
Filing for bankruptcy prevents most creditors from pursuing legal action against you to collect a debt. Most debts discharge through bankruptcy, except for some tax liens and student loans.
Under a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, the court entirely writes off most debts. Individuals who don’t meet the qualifications for a Chapter 7 bankruptcy may file for Chapter 13.
Under Chapter 13, the court discharges some debts, and other liabilities are reorganized through a payment plan. Individuals must adhere to a unique payment schedule with a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.
Filing for bankruptcy prevents debt collectors from pursuing legal action against you to collect a debt. Instead, they must comply with the rules of your bankruptcy and accept whatever payments the court orders you to make.
Under most state laws, a sheriff or officer of the court must deliver a court summons directly to you. If they fail to do so, you may argue that you never received the summons and were unaware of the lawsuit against you.
However, a defense of improper summons does not mean that the debt collector will not pursue further actions against you. The Affirmative Defense may help delay collection, but the creditor can always refile their lawsuit and ensure you receive the next summons.
Sometimes, people add authorized users to their credit cards or other financial accounts. Authorized users may pay the bill or review the account information. Usually, people add authorized users when another person handles the household finances or for transparency in their relationship.
Authorized users are not liable for paying off an old credit card debt. As long as they are not jointly responsible for the account, a debt collector cannot sue them to collect old balances.
If a debt collector files a lawsuit against you to collect more than the original balance that you owed, you may have grounds to dispute the case. A debt collector cannot charge you more than the original balance; if they do, you must agree to the changes.
When you first receive notice from a debt collector that they are attempting to collect an old debt of yours, make sure you require them to validate the amount due. Compare it to your records. If it does not match and they attempt to sue you, you may use the documentation in your defense.
Under the US Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 8(c) states:
“(c) Affirmative Defenses.
(1) In General. In responding to a pleading, a party must affirmatively state any avoidance or affirmative defense, including:
In other words, if you’re being sued for a debt, you must list any affirmative defenses in your initial response called the Answer. If you do not, you won’t be able to bring up these defenses later in the case.
Now, if you’re like most people, you probably don’t know what most of these words mean in the legal context.
Luckily, SoloSuit helps you figure out which affirmative defenses to use in your Answer document and translates them into legal terms for you. All you have to do is respond to a set of questions about your case, and your affirmative defenses will be automatically generated for you.
SoloSuit makes it easy to fight debt collectors.
You can use SoloSuit to respond to a debt lawsuit, to send letters to collectors, and even to settle a debt.
SoloSuit's Answer service is a step-by-step web-app that asks you all the necessary questions to complete your Answer. Upon completion, we'll have an attorney review your document and we'll file it for you.
"First time getting sued by a debt collector and I was searching all over YouTube and ran across SoloSuit, so I decided to buy their services with their attorney reviewed documentation which cost extra but it was well worth it! SoloSuit sent the documentation to the parties and to the court which saved me time from having to go to court and in a few weeks the case got dismissed!" – James
You can ask your questions on the SoloSuit forum and the community will help you out. Whether you need help now or are just looking for support, we're here for you.
Here's a list of guides for other states.
Being sued by a different debt collector? Were making guides on how to beat each one.
Is your credit card company suing you? Learn how you can beat each one.
Need more info on statutes of limitations? Read our 50-state guide.
Need help managing your finances? Check out these resources.